A.G. Gardiner’s essay "On Saying Please" is a classic piece of social philosophy. It explores the "minor" virtues of politeness and civility, arguing that while rudeness isn't a legal crime, it is a social one that poisons the atmosphere of human interaction. Summary The essay begins with an incident involving a lift-man who threw a passenger out of his lift because the passenger refused to say "Please" when requesting the Top Floor. While the lift-man was legally in the wrong (one cannot physically assault someone for being rude), Gardiner uses this to discuss the "invisible" laws of social conduct. Gardiner argues that while the law protects us against physical violence, it cannot protect us against "incivility." If we were allowed to hit people for being rude, the streets would be "running with blood." However, he emphasizes that even though bad manners aren't a crime, they are often more damaging than physical b...